Clavicle fracture Comparison of three treatment.docVIP

 PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 14 Clavicle fracture Comparison of three treatment Of: Zhang Yonghua, Yichang Miao, Li vertical flight, Li Zhiyong [Abstract] Objective To compare the analysis of modified Kirschner wire Kirschner wire and an ordinary three internal fixation with reconstruction plate the clinical efficacy of treatment of fracture. Methods selected 173 cases of clavicle fractures were randomly divided into three groups, A group of 50 cases, B group of 88 cases, C group of 35 patients. were to be modified Kirschner wire Kirschner wire and an ordinary three internal fixation with reconstruction plate to observe the three groups of operative time, hospital stay, postoperative complications, clinical and medical expenses. Results were followed up 5 to 20 months, average 11.5 months. c The mean operative time, length of stay and average medical costs were significantly different (P lt;0.01), where B, A group of less than C, B group was less than the A group (P lt;0.05 or 0.01); excellent rate of three groups showed no significant difference (Pgt; 0.05), complication rates were significantly different (P lt;0.01), A, C Group lower than B (P lt;0.05 0.01), C group and A was no significant difference (Pgt; 0.05). comprehensive judgments, A group of better overall effect. Conclusion improved external locking intramedullary fixation Keshi Zhen clavicle fractures can lower health care costs to achieve the desired clinical effect, compared to ordinary steel Kirschner wire is more cheap and efficient and reconstruction, especially for primary hospital. [Keywords:] clavicular fracture; internal fixation; modified Kirschner wire [Abstract] Objective To compare and analyze the clinical efficacy of improved Kirschner wire, common Kirschner wire and reconstraction plate as internal fixation modes in treatment of clavicular fracture.Methods Retrospective analysis was performed in 173 patients who were diagnosed with clavicular fracture and treated by surgery duri