从韩凤群案看精神障碍人的刑事责任-刑事诉讼法专业论文.docxVIP

作 者 姓 名： 魏再金 指 导 教 师： 戴勇才 西 南 政 法 大 学 Southwest University of Political Science and Law 内容摘要 俗话说虎毒不食子，一个温和慈爱的母亲居然对自己的亲身骨肉下手，这个离奇的 悲剧母亲吸引了社会众多人士的关注，一审法院判处韩凤群故意杀人罪成立，处有期徒 刑五年，该案引发了较为激烈的讨论，到底韩凤群构不构成故意杀人罪？韩凤群该不该 从轻处罚？如果该从轻处罚，理由根据又是什么？本文拟对韩凤群溺子案的定罪和量刑 进行分析，以期能对司法实践有所裨益。全文共分四部分： 第一部分叙述基本案情，首先引出韩凤群案件的案由案情，进而整理归纳相关的争 议焦点。 第二部分，重点对对韩凤群案的定罪和相关的问题进行分析，侧重分析对韩凤群不 作为犯罪处理的观点，并对该观点进行反驳，然后提出自己的观点，从事实和法律两方 面阐述韩凤群构成故意杀人罪 第三部分，主要对韩凤群溺子案的量刑进行分析。这部分主要对赞成韩凤群案从轻 处罚的人的观点进行分析，然后提出自己的观点，为韩凤群做从轻处罚的辩护。 第四部分是案后反思，首先理性分析韩凤群溺子的原因，从而分析我国的残疾人救 济制度和我国犯罪的预防机制。 关键词：韩凤群；故意杀人；定罪；量刑；从轻 It is well-known to everyone that all men, good or bad, rarely kill their own children, but Han Fengqun killed her sun herself. This tragic mother attracted attention of people around this country. The court sentenced Han Fengqun intentional homicide and measured an imprisonment for five years in the first trial. The case has triggered a more fierce discussion. Does Han Fengqun constitute intentional homicide? Whether Han Fengqun deserves a lighter punishment or not? If the lighter punishment is reasonable, what is the reason? This article intends to conviction and sentencing of the Han Fengqun drowning children case analysis, in order to be beneficial to the judicial practice. The paper is divided into four parts. The first part describes the basic facts of the case which leads to Han’s tragedy. Then the author focuses on summarizing the facts and discussing the controversial issues of this case. The second part focuses on the conviction and related problems, particularly on the point that Han Fengqun was not guilty. Then the author analyses the point, and come up with his own view based on the fact and the rules. The third part focuses on the measurement of the punishment. This part includes the view of lighter measurement and the point of the author himself. The forth part mainly describes the related problems of the case. In this part the author will give his advice on establishing help-system for the disabled and