从裁的量二元论到裁量一元论.doc

从裁的量二元论到裁量一元论.doc

从裁量二元论到裁量一元论 王天华 摘 要:裁量二元论长期以来是行政法领域中的支配性理论,它把裁量问题与法律问题作为各自独立的二元来理解;裁量一元论正好相反,它认为裁量问题与法律问题并非各自独立的二元,根本不存在不受法律拘束的自由裁量。裁量一元论自20 世纪中期以来,随着大陆法系国家法院对行政裁量态度的转变而逐渐抬头;20 世纪后期以来,更有取代裁量二元论之势。这一现象意味着大陆法系国家行政裁量观念发生了质变,其直接原因是“裁量滥用”法理的展开,更深层次的原因则是是法治国家理念的质变。 关键词:裁量二元论;裁量一元论;自由裁量;裁量滥用 Abstract :The discretionary dualism has long been the dominated theory in administrative law field , which understands the discretionary problem and legal problemfrom two independent points1 On the contrary , the discretionary monism considers that there exists no discretion that is not restricted by law This idea has become p

文档评论(0)

1亿VIP精品文档

相关文档