2016 - Maestro：A System for Scalable OpenFlow Control.pdfVIP

160 W/O batching 140 With batching d n o c 120 e s o r c i m 100 t, n e p 80 s e m i t l 60 a t o T 40 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Number of packets to send Under maximum input rate 800000 80 d System throughput n o Times of 0 pending request left c 700000 70 e t f s e / l s t 600000 60 t s s e e u u q q e 500000 50 e r r w g n o i l f 400000 40 d , n t e u p p h 300000 30 0 g f u o o r s h 200000 20 e t m m i T e t 100000 10 s y S 0 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Pending requests threshhold Under maximum input rate 800000 1600 d System throughput n o Average delay c 700000 1400 e s / d s t 600000 1200 n s o e c u e q s i e 500000 1000 l l r i w m o , l y f 400000 800 a , l t e u p d h 300000 600 e g g u a o r r e h 200000 400 v Under variable input rate t A m e 65536 t 100000 200 NOX, singled threaded, all features N/A s y Maestro, single threaded, all features disabled S 16384 0 0 Maestro, single threaded, all features enabled 1 10 100 1000 10000 d 4096 Maestro, 7 worker threads, all features enabled n o Input batching threshhold c e 1024 s i l l i m 256 , y a l 64 e d e 16 g a r e 4 v A 1 0.25 4096 16384 65536 262144 1.04858e+06 Requests input rate upperbound Under maximum input rate 800000 d W/O core binding, W/O thread binding n o W/O core binding, With thread binding c 700000 e With core binding, W/O thread binding s / With core binding, With thread binding s t 600000 s e u q e 500000 r w o l f 400000 , t u p h 300000 g u o r 200000 h t m e t 100000 s y S 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Number of worker threads Under maximum input rate 1400 W/O core binding, W/O thread binding W/O core binding, With thread binding With core binding, W/O thread binding d 1200 With core binding, With thread binding n o c e 1000 s i l l i m , 800 y 100 a l e d 600 e g a r 80 e 400 v A e g a 200 t n e 60 c r 0 e p 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 e v i Number of worker threads t a 40 l u m u C 20 Maestro with 60000rp