科学研究的选题过程课件.pptVIP

Referee’s Report Form for Submitted Papers Main reasons for your decision ? Accept because of (1) the originality (good ideas, sound presentation) (2) the quality of the proposed synthesis (useful review on recent advances) Rewrite (PLS indicate what has to be Revised) Referee’s Report Form for Submitted Papers Main reasons for your decision ? Reject because (1) it is not relevant to (not appropriate) … (2) of the presentation(so poorly written that contributions, if any, are obscure). (3) the content is too premature (4) of lack of originality (5) of major errors (