How to write a review UNSW School of CSE如何写评论CSE新南威尔士大学.pptVIP

How to write a review Toby Walsh Department of Computer Science University of York www.cs.york.ac.uk/~tw/phd Outline What is a review? Why should you review? How do you review a paper? What not to do? What are the dilemmas? Case study What is a review? “Something that will ruin your day” Alan Bundy Even if it is good! The stamp of scientific quality Feedback from your peers Future directions? What is a review not? Acceptance/rejection Editors/Program committees accept/reject You recommend! A place for bias, prejudice, personal animosity, … Though it often appears to be so Why should you rev