关于花岗岩成因分类与花岗岩成矿作_省略_基本问题的思考_与张旗先生等商榷_华仁民.pdfVIP

2011 2 30 1 February, 2011 MINERAL DEPOSITS Vol. 30 No. 1 : 0258 7106 (2011) 01 0163 08 ) ) ) 与张旗先生等商榷X 华仁民 ( , , 210093) 56 2010 5 (2010)/ 0 , Sr Yb 4 3 : ; SrYb ; , ; , , ( ) , (2010) / 0 / 0 ; ; ; SrYb ; ; : P588;P611 :A On some basic problems related to the genetic classification and mineralization of granites: A discussion with Mr. Zhang Qi HUA RenMin ( State Key Laboratory of Mineral Deposit Research, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, Jiangsu, China) Abstract As regards some important viewpoints on the genetic classification and related mineralization of granites from the paper ÷Relationship between granitic rocks and Au Cu W Sn mineralization written by Zhang Qi et al. ( called ÷Zhang s paper for short) in Mineral Deposits, the present author raises several doubts and ques tions for discussion. T he classification put forward by ÷Zhang s paper has three problems, i. e. , 1, adakite as a special type of granitic rocks cannot be employed as one of the genetic types of granitoids; 2, Sr and Yb con centrations of granites do not have definite property as an indicator of genetic classification of granites; 3, the names of granite types such as Himalaya, Zhe Min, and Nanling used by ÷Zhang s paper cannot well represent and incorporate all granites in these areas. It is pointed out that both W Sn and Cu Au deposits related to granitic rocks are mainly of hydrothermal geneses, and hence have close genetic relations with granitic rocks. X ( 2007CB411404) ( 4107303540730423) , , 1946 , Email: huarenmin@ nju.