Appeal成功经历_意见.docVIP

============第一次审稿意见============= Dear Dr. AAA, I am writing to you concerning the above referenced manuscript, which you submitted to the KKK. Based on the enclosed set of reviews, it was recommended that the manuscript be REVISED AND RESUBMITTED (RQ). 【具体审稿意见略】 ============Reject 意见============= Dear Dr. AAA, I am writing to you concerning the above referenced manuscript, which you submitted to the KKK Journal. Based on the enclosed set of reviews, this manuscript has been REJECTED for publication ************ The main reason for rejecting this paper is that you failed to address some major issues raised by one reviewer without any explanations. Thisy is considered unacceptable by the Transactions. ************ While the decision of the Associate Editor may not be positive, based on the comments of the reviewers, you may wish to consider and implement these comments. The current decision does not prevent your future submission of the reworked manuscript, which will receive appropriate peer review as a new submission. Thank you for considering KKK Journal for publication of your work. * If you have any questions regarding the reviews, please contact the Associate Editor who managed your paper. ============Appeal内容============= Dear Associate Editor LLLL, It is really a bad news for us to receive a rejection letter of the revised manuscript, especially for our waiting for more than five months since its submission. We read and analyzed the decision letter and the comments of the reviewers more carefully. It is really our duty for the rejection of the revised manuscript. We forgot to explain the comment from one of the reviewers about a [具体问题], because we were absorbed in the programming and adding comparisons with the XXX method. An explanation for the [具体问题] of the proposed method and the YYY method are really not so difficult. Now, the corresponding comparisons and explanations are given in detail in the new revision description. We find that our meth