EvaluationForm.docVIP

MINI-REVIEWS IN MEDICINAL CHEMISTRY Manuscript Evaluation Form Editor-in-Chief: Atta-ur-Rahman, FRS (HEJ Research Institute of Chemistry, University of Karachi, Pakistan) M. Iqbal Choudhary ( H.E.J. Research Institute of Chemistry, University of Karachi, Karachi-75270, Pakistan) George Perry (College of Sciences, The University of Texas at SanAntonio, One UTSA Circle, San Antonio, Texas, USA) URL: /mrmc Instructions for Authors: /mrmc/MSandI.htm PAPER TITLE AUTHOR(S) NAME MC/-MS-?????? REFEREES ASSESSMENT (cross as appropriate) Criterion Excellent Good Fair Poor Originality of the topic × Technical Quality × Importance in Its Field × Style Overall Representation × Extends the previous study × Readily Understandable × Suitability for Journal × Interesting for a Non-Expert × Adequate Illustrations or Drawings × English language is good enough × Overall the Paper is Rated (Excellent ------------------------------------------ Poor) 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 REFEREES RECOMMENDATIONS OTHER SPECIFIC CRITICISMS Accept with minor changes Imperfect style Accept subject to revisions, as noted in comments √ Too long Reject in current form, but may be resubmitted References incorrectly presented Reject, with no resubmission Typographical and Grammatical errors √ PAPER TYPE: Research article Review article Letter article Confidential Comments to the Editor (not for Transmission to Authors): Though the paper addresses an important issue and may interest a wider audience the following points need to be addressed.The language of the paper has to be improved considerably throughout. Comments for the Authors (continue on another sheet, if necessary): The pictu