《Journal of Hydrology》投稿经过.docVIP

【原创】《Journal of Hydrology》再次失败... 已有3人参与  小木虫(金币+1):奖励一下，鼓励发有价值的话题最近看有虫虫把一年前的贴子“地学口的朋友，有投过《Journal of Hydrology》的么”又续上讨论了 （/bbs/viewthread. ... ghlight=page=1），其实我本不打算再更新了，但确实又想再留下些什么，无奈原贴主文已无法进行编辑，所以另开一篇，算是我这篇稿件冲击JH的一个过程说明吧，希望能对地学口或是想投JH期刊的虫虫有所帮助！虽不是学水文学出身，但垂涎 Journal of Hydrology期刊由来已久。电脑里Endnote中也是JH的期刊文献最多（因为平时读的最多）。这已经是我第二篇稿件冲击JH了，可惜还是失败，之前篇投JH被拒的稿件改投IF=1。3的期刊，目前正小修中。言归正传吧[2009-07-02] 稿件新投稿[2009-07-03] 稿子分配了Manuscript No，状态变为Editor Assigned[2009-07-06] 稿子状态还是Editor Assigned，但时间更新了一下[2009-07-24] 稿子状态还是Editor Assigned，但时间再次更新[2009-08-12] 我有点等不及了，给editor发了封电邮去催了催[2009-09-01] 稿子状诚变为reviewer invited [2009-09-03] 稿子状态变为under review[2009-11-03] 稿子状态不变，还是“under review”，但时间更新了！[2009-12-02] 稿子状态变为with editor[2009-12-03] 稿子状态变为Decision in Process[2009-12-08] Reject，同时收到comments！*****************************************************************************Dear ***,I very much regret to have to tell you that publication in our journal is not recommended. An explanation for this decision is given in the attached review reports (and on /hydrol/). I hope that the comments contained therein will be of use to you.Thank you for your interest in our journal.With kind regards,Andreas Bardossy EditorJournal of HydrologyReviewer #1: Comments on paper by ***. submitted to Journal of HydrologyThis paper addressed **** by analyzing ****. Generally, it is a kind of conventional research. Actually, overwhelmingly abundant studies are available concerning ****. Any more similar studies will not further help to understand ****. Besides, to my best knowledge, there are some studies addressing *****. Repeated studies of similar topics are not attractive and impressive. There are other similar studies and I can not list them all here. The authors should thoroughly review and discuss the previous studies, addressing the novelty of the current study when compared to the previous ones. I think the publication of the study in the Journal of Hydrology requires nove