仪顾堂书目题跋汇编整理中存在的几个问题.PDFVIP

郑晓霞：《仪顾堂书目题跋汇编》整理中存在的几个问题 Zheng Xiaoxia: Several Problems Exist in the Arrangement of Yi Gu Tang Bibliography Compilation of Postscripts : The Case Relates to Yi Gu Tang Work Set   107 《仪顾堂书目题跋汇编》整理中存在的几个问题 ——以涉及《仪顾堂集》部分为例 郑晓霞（华东师范大学图书馆） 摘  要  晚清藏书家陆心源一生撰有众多书目题跋，学术价值向来为学界所重视。中华书局出版 的《仪顾堂书目题跋汇编》第一次将陆氏所撰书目题跋整合整理，不仅惠及士林，也进一步提升 了文献的自身价值。然而，由于整理者在学识素养以及治学态度方面存在的一些缺失，导致该 《汇编》出现了一些不容忽视的问题。本文以其中所涉《仪顾堂集》部分为例，就这些问题试作 讨论，以期对该编本身及读者有所裨益。 关键词  《仪顾堂书目题跋汇编》 问题 DOI: 10.13663/ki.lj.2015.07.018 Several Problems Exist in the Arrangement of Yi Gu Tang Bibliography Compilation of Postscripts: The Case Relates to Yi Gu Tang Work Set Zheng Xiaoxia (East China Normal University Library) Abstract In the late Qing bibliophile Lu Xinyuan life had written numerous books postscripts, academic value has always been valued by scholars. Yi Gu Tang Bibliography Compilation of Postscripts published by Zhonghua first integrated and arranged the bibliography of postscripts written by Lu Xinyuan , not only benefit scholars, but also further enhance the self value. However, due to some deficiency exists in the knowledge consolidation and scholarly attitude, leading to some problems that can’t be ignored in this version .In this paper, we will study these problems take those fragments which involved in Yi Gu Tong Work Set as example, in order to benefit the series itself and the readers. Key words Yi Gu Tang Bibliography Compilation of Postscripts, Problems 陆心源是晚清四大藏书家之一，不仅以 生这一嘉惠士林之举的同时，也注意到《汇 藏书闳富闻名当时，在文献学、版本学方面 编》在整理中存在不少问题，或多或少损伤了 的成就也一直为后世所称道。尤其是他所撰 其学术价值。关于这一问题，已有相关学人撰 写的众多书目题跋，于“版刻源流，收藏姓 文进行讨论，[2] 然似有未尽之处。今仅以其中 [1] 其价值向来备 所涉《仪顾堂集》部分为例，对此作进一步 氏，剖析异同，如指诸掌”， 受学界所重。2009 年，中华书局出版了由冯 讨论。 惠民先生整理的《仪顾堂书目题跋汇编》（以 下简称《汇编》），将陆氏所著《仪顾堂题跋》 1  治学态度不严谨导致的问题 《仪顾堂续跋》《仪顾堂集》中所涉书目题跋以