论已撤销国际商事仲裁裁决的承认和执行-法学·国际私法专业论文.docxVIP

销仲裁裁决的标准，最后对《纽约公约》关于该问题的规定作详细分析。本文认 销仲裁裁决的标准，最后对《纽约公约》关于该问题的规定作详细分析。本文认 为，《纽约公约》的立法历史以及第五条和第七条的规定和措辞为已撤销裁决可以 承认和执行提供了法律依据。 第三章为已撤销仲裁裁决可执行性的理论探讨。本章首先从根源上即仲裁裁 决效力来源来探究已撤销裁决的可执行性，认为仲裁协议是仲裁裁决的直接效力 来源，仲裁地国法是仲裁裁决的间接效力来源．仲裁裁决的撤销并不当然具有域 外效力。其次对仲裁“非内国化”理论作出评析，认为仲裁“非内国化”理论并 未被广泛接受，仲裁程序能否排除仲裁地国仲裁法中的相关强制性规则是值得怀 疑的，并认为依据《纽约公约》来执行“非内国化裁决”并不利于公约的统一性 和权威性。最后探讨了撤销仲裁裁决制度存在的必要性和各国关于撤销制度的立 法趋向。 第四章为己撤销仲裁裁决在我国的可执行性及我国撤销仲裁裁决制度的完 善。首先依据我国相关法律及司法解释的规定，本文认为：一方面，己撤销仲裁 裁决在我国不存在可执行性，建议我国立法依据《纽约公约》在措辞上做些变通， 在一定条件下考虑承认和执行已撤销裁决的可能性；另一方面，“非内国化裁决” 在我国没有出现的可能性。其次，鉴于法、美等国承认和执行已撤销裁决的实践， 我国必须对撤销涉外仲裁裁决制度存在的缺陷和问题及时作出修订，避免被我国 法院撤销的裁决在他国以不合理的理由得到承认和执行。 [关键词]：撤销仲裁裁决承认和执行可执行性仲裁“非内国化” A A Study on the Recognition and Enforcement of Annulled InternationaI Arbitral Awards (Abstract) Major：International Law Specialty：Intemational PriVate Law Author：Jiang Rensuo Tutor：Prof．Liu Xiaohong In traditional opinion，arbitral awards attached themselves to the national law of a certain country．When it had been annulled by the authority of the place of arbitration， the arbitral award was not existent，so it cannot be recognized and enforeed not only by the country of the place of arbitration，but also by other countries．But in practice， arbitral awards which had been annulled by other country were recognized and enforced in France once and again，and similar cases took place in other countries such as USA，Belgiarn and Austria etc．Moreover,the expression and stipulation of the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards provide possibility to enforce annulled arbitral awards．After the arbitral award of the case (Chromalloy Aeroservices v Egypt)was annulled by the court of Egypt inl997，it still recognized and enforced by the court of USA and France in 1 998．The．experts of arbitration law debated drastically on the problem of‘‘enforceability of annulled arbitral awards”from several aspects include the standard of enforceability,application and interpretation of New York Convention and maintenance o