能力谱方法在梁桥抗震性能评价中的比较研究-地震工程与工程振动.pdf

28 6 Vo.l 28 No. 6 2008 12 JOURNAL OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEER ING AND ENG INEERING V IBRATION Dec. 2008 : 1000- 1301( 2008) 06- 0090- 0 袁万城, 杨 俊, 冯清海 ( , 200092) :, , , 9 6, , , , 0. 65 s 30% , 30% , , , , : ; ; : P315. 95 : A Com pa rative study on capacity spectrum m ethods fo r estim ating seism ic perform ance of girder bridges YUAN W ancheng, YANG Jun, FENG Q inghai ( State K ey Laboratory for D isaster R eduction in C ivil Engineering, TongjiUniv. , Shanghai 200092, china) Abs tract: In this paper, the fundamental theory and app lication procedure of capacity spectrum m ethod are intro- duced, a comparison of calculation principles and application procedures among five mi proved capacity spectrum methods is made, and a d iscussion on the characters of thesem ethods ismade too. Then, tak ing the results of non- linear tmi e history analysis as a standard, the target disp lacements of these five capacity spectrum methods for 9 smi plified girder bridgemodelsw ith m iddle- low periods in the longitudinal d irection subjected to 6 ground motions are estmi ated, and a comparison of the accuracy among these fivemethods ismade. The resu lts show that, the error discrepancy of the first three system sw ith low periods is bigger than the others, and the error for the system sw ith period greater than 0. 65s ism ainly in the range of 30%, and the amount of resu ltsw ith errorw ith in 30% for method w ith inelastic spectra is greater than that w ith elastic spectra. Besides, the peak acceleration for response spectrum of both wt o earthquake ground motions, w here better accuracy is gained , i