红学专题史编撰刍议.pdfVIP

125 红学专题史编撰鱼议 红学专题史编撰当议 杜志军 提 要 作为学术史类型之一，专题学术史向来占有重要的地位。 1980 年以来，以 红学分期、红学人物、红学流派、红学方法论、国别红学为本位的五类红学史著作大量问 世，但红学专题史迄今尚未引起足够的重视。比较而言，红学专题史既可弥补以红学分期 为本位的通史类或断代史类红学史著分散悬隔、繁累重复的局限，又能超越流派本 位红学史著的跨派的谬误而兼顾红学现象的丰富性。它可以比人物本位的列传、单传 式红学史著或国别红学涵盖更宽广的红学视域，同时又能给红学方法论的讨论提供广阔 的天地。本文在检讨三十余年来诸种红学史著作的基础上，探讨了红学专题史的学术史 价值及体例特点，并就其编撰原则和撰述体例提出了尝试性的建议。 关键词红楼梦红学红学史红学专题史 A Discussion on the Compilation of A History of Special Topics in Redology 7L n . 冒 . 冒 . D u un •• d Abstract: As a type of an academic history , Special Topic Academic History is an important one all the way. Since 1980 , five types of Redology history works , including a period of Redology , characters of Redology , sectors of Redology , methodology of Redology and region of Redology , have come out in quantity. But the Special Topic History of Redology still lacks regard nowadays. Comparatively speaking , the Special Topic History of Redology is not only the supplement to the deficiencies such as incompleteness or redundancy of general history or dynastic histOIγbased on the period of Redology , but also a solution to the misunderstanding between multi-sectors based on sectors of Redology , which maintains the diversity of Redology. Furthermore , the view of Special Topic History of Redology is