{合同知识}合作办学合同书.docxVIP

ABC A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V 由此 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V {合同知识}合作办学合同书 HCA1221/2006 INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTHE HONGKONGSPECIALADMINISTRATIVEREGION COURTOFFIRSTINSTANCE ACTIONNO.1221OF2006 ____________ BETWEEN PINEENTERPRISESLIMITEDPlaintiff and CYBERSTRATEGYLIMITED1stDefendant LECTUREKITCOMPANYLIMITED2ndDefendant and WOOPAKHAYEDWARD1stThirdParty LAWSHIUKAIANDREW2ndThirdParty ____________ HCCW593/2005 INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTHE HONGKONGSPECIALADMINISTRATIVEREGION COURTOFFIRSTINSTANCE COMPANIESWINDING-UPPROCEEDINGSNO.593OF2005 ____________ INTHEMATTERofUnionResources(EducationalDevelopment)Limited ANDINTHEMATTERofSections168Aand177(1)(f)oftheCompaniesOrdinance(Cap32) BETWEEN PINEENTERPRISESLIMITEDPetitioner and LECTUREKITCOMPANYLIMITED1stRespondent UNIONRESOURCES2ndRespondent (EDUCATIONALDEVELOPMENT)LIMITED ____________ (HCA1221/2006andHCCW593/2005areheardandtriedtogetherpursuanttotheorderofHighCourtJudgePoondated31July2007) Before:DeputyHighCourtJudgeToinCourt DatesofHearing:17-21,24-25,27-28September2007, 2-3October2007,5-6,8-9,12-14November2007, 4,7-8,14,30-31January2008and1,4February2008 DateofJudgment:14March2008 _______________ JUDGMENT _______________ ABCDEFGHIJ A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V 由此 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V INTRODUCTION Thisisatrialoftwoactions,namelyHCCW593/2005andHCA1221/2006,orderedtobetriedtogetherpursuanttotheorderofPoonJ.ThedisputearoseoutoffouragreementsinconnectionwiththesalebyPineEnterprisesLimited(“Pine”)ofitssharesinUnionResources(EducationalDevelopment)Limited(“URLimited”)toLectureKitCompanyLimited(“LectureKit”).ThesharesinURLimitedweredulytransferredtoLectureKiton13May2003.Pineplainedofbreachoftheagreements.On1August2005,PinepetitionedforthewindingupofURLimitedonjustandequitablegroundunderHCCW593/2005.On7June2006,PinealsomencedactionHCA1221/2006againstLectureKitanditsparentpanyCyberStrategyLimited(“CyberStrategy”)forbreachofagreement.CyberStrategyandLectureKitcounterclaimedaga