科技论文的选题.pptVIP

科技论文的选题、写作和评价

崔金钟

;科技论文的选题;科学研究过程;科学研究过程;科学研究过程;科学研究过程;科学研究过程;ScientificPaperEvaluationForm

Score(2=always,1=sometimes,

0=rarelyornever)

Title:??2

Introduction:??4

ProcedureorMaterialsandMethods:?4

Results:???????10

Discussion:????8

LiteratureCited:?6

Overall:???6

TotalGradingScore:___/40=___% ?;ScientificPaperEvaluationForm

Title:

descriptiveandappropriate?

Introduction:??

1,sufficientbackgroundinformationso

purposeofstudyisclear? ?

? ???2,hypothesisand/orobjective(s)of

studyclearlystated ?

ProcedureorMaterialsandMethods: ?

? ????1,aremethodsclearlydescribed? ?

? ????2,researchdesignisappropriate ?

;ScientificPaperEvaluationForm

Results:

1,cleartextdescriptionofresults ?

? ???2,figuresand/ortablesreferredtointext

3,figuresand/ortablesareessential,proper

format,and“standalone”withclear

captions ?

? ???4,allrelevantdataispresented? ?

? ???5,areresultsadequatelyanalyzedby

appropriatestatistical?methods?

Discussion:

????1,?allrelevantdatadiscussed? ?

? ??2,datajustifiesconclusions/interpretations?

? ??3,facts,calculations,andinterpretations

correct? ?

? ??4,interpretations/conclusionscomparedwith

publishedworks? ?

;ScientificPaperEvaluationForm

LiteratureCited: ?

? ?1,sufficientandappropriate(related)for

scopeofstudy? ?

? ?2,correctcitationmethodologyinbodyoftext

(authordateformat)? ?

? ?3,correctbibliographicformat? ?

Overall:

1,reportisclearlywrittenandlogically

organized? ?

? ?2,understandingofcontentclearlydemonstrated

byauthor? ?

? ?3,spellingandgrammarOK,easytoread? ?

;《植物学报》审稿单;Whyisitdifficulttopublish?;Whyisitdifficultt