公诉权和刑事审判监督权关系及其配置问题再探——兼论二种权能之协调履行.pdfVIP

摘要 摘要 对赋孑砬系飒关刑事审判监督权的合理性、控诉权与刑事审判盟驽权是否 应由检察机关统一行使等问题的争辩，归根结底是在两种权能在关系论和配置 论上分别采取何种立场的问题。对此，笔者试图在辨析公诉权的监督属性和厘 清刑事审判监督投与俏关概念的种属和界限上，批驳在关系论上的“形式分立 说”、在配置论上的“统一行使论”等主张，并提倡两种权能在关系沦上采用“实 质分立说”，在配置论上采用“修正的统一行使论”的立场，同时对当前的权利 配置模式进行反思，进而提出相关的修改和完善建议。 关键词：公诉权；审判监督权；协调 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT The onthe ofWhetherthe shouldbe argumentrationality procuratorialagency entrustedwithcriminal theaccusationfunctionand judgmentsupervisoryauthority,if criminal shouldbeexecuted the judgmentsupervisoryauthority uniformlyby thefmal isthe what thetwo procuratorialagency,in analysis argumentposition sidesstandon andallocation to this，the authorityfunctionrelationship theory．As writertriedtoadvocatesubstance on andmodified separationtheoryrelationship of on than offormfrom allocation,rather theoryuniformlyexecuting separation contentand the natureof uniformlyexecuting，byanalyzingsupervisionprosecution the and ofcriminal and right，Clarifyspeciesboundary judgmentsupervisoryauthority its thesame writer currentmodeon relatingconcept．At time,theintrospected right allocationandcome modificationand up、析t11corresponding improvementproposal． KeyWords：prosecution；trialsupervision；coordination