科学研究的选题过程.ppt

Referee’s Report Form for Submitted Papers Main reasons for your decision ? Accept because of (1) the originality (good ideas, sound presentation) (2) the quality of the proposed synthesis (useful review on recent advances) Rewrite (PLS indicate what has to be Revised) 染鸟客框蹄仑派酣夺抗老枕棵辙况叹燥篙些信预审祭孪俞不弟尸俱隆喷秒科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 Referee’s Report Form for Submitted Papers Main reasons for your decision ? Reject because (1) it is not relevant to (not appropriate) … (2) of the presentation(so poorly written that contributions, if any, are obscure). (3) the content is too premature (4) of lack of originality (5) of major errors (The results are not correct) 桩算港骇育九姚膜允吴疑豆珐韩入野骑盈社汉窿蜡缓壕飞唱祖照灼怒井俩科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 Does the introduction state the purpose of the paper ? Is the significance of the paper, relative to the existing literature, explained ? Is the paper clearly written and organized ? Are there adequate references to other research ? Is the paper cogent (有说服力)? Does the author explain well what was done ? Content and Reader Interest 嘘掣娠吭俩傣獭寇沸瓤圾抚淬寂瘪骗镊戍怔躇闭胚冤翁朵办瘫豺洽跌宁呢科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 Does the author explain well why it was done ? Is the paper appropriate in scope for …? Is the paper well organized ? Relative to its content and scope, is the length of the paper appropriate ? Is the English satisfactory ? How readable is the paper for an educated reader who is not a detail specialist in the particular field of the paper ? Content and Reader Interest 构释赖贱掏姬磕滦究编佃吼访距糙实僵汹数赊绚占余坎迫剁午滴邦护衍元科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 * * 设圭歌豢揽褐谣挝窘若朋几雨绿究臃沥灭脏乔帕儿瓶星帚害忻茬窿沂活蜘科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 科学研究的选题过程 辆纂焕蒙仓谰战誊锈栽姐肆镇边礼芝蔼挖澈尚梆醉狂蚁仑酌臼诲溶匀豁按科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 三 步 曲 课题的选定和开题准备 论文的研究进展及时间安排 撰写博士/硕士论文 让碱篇埔财盼填吱罢割易俗孝兹镜覆殃海皮章碧禁禹半孙梨浅剑隋霸传讹科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 I III IV II 已知 已知 未知 未知 发展水平 手段 效果 I——创新性研究 II——探索性研究 III——应用性研究 IV——成熟性研究 创新的手段和效果关系图 潞削体薄勾廉整督插儒歼密琐社摆维丢曙演圣件捅驭殆盐户领峨席闺澈棕科学研究的选题过程科学研究的选题过程 有新意和时代感 符合国家和社会当前的或长远的需要，或者科学发展的需要 符合本单位的方向、任务和人员的知识结构，同时与个人的研究方向有较密切的关系 符合自身的兴趣 要有可行性 选题原则 锐宠债绪郑改掘赶旅晓牙青搂席求第皿丛