Monogrammic Determinism Stilian Morrison Department of….pdfVIP

Monogrammic Determinism? Stilian Morrison, Department of Economics, Pomona College, Claremont, CA 91711 Gary Smith, Ph.D., Department of Economics, Pomona College, Claremont, CA 91711 Correspondence: Gary Smith Pomona College Claremont, California 91711 909-607-3135; fax: 909-621-8576 gsmith@ 3591 words, 2 tables, 2 figures * We are very grateful to the editors and reviewers for their careful, detailed, and extraordinarily helpful suggestions. 1 Monogrammic Determinism? Stilian Morrison Gary Smith Abstract Objective: Attempt to replicate a report that people whose names have positive initials (such as ACE or VIP) live much longer than do people with negative initials (such as PIG or DIE). The primary analysis in the original 1969-1995 study grouped decedents by year of death; however, average age at death (AAD) calculations for decedents grouped in this way can be misleading if the frequency of initials changes over time. Grouping the decedents by birth year solves this problem and provides a more natural test of whether there is a statistical relationship between initials and longevity. Methods: The California Department of Health Services mortality data base was used to identify the birth year and age at death of decedents with positive or negative initials, as defined by the original study and as chosen by a new survey. Results: There is no substantial or statistically significant relationship between either set of initials and longevity when decedents are grouped by birth year, either for the original study period 1969-1995 or for the longer period 1905-2003. Conclusion: These data do not