who -DFAT-WHO water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) Evaluation across the Asia Pacific (-) Report-此为英文文档.docx

EvaluationReportforDFAT-WHO

water,sanitationandhygiene

(WASH)EvaluationacrosstheAsia

Pacific2018-2022.FinalReport.

2

TableofContents

Acknowledgements 5

ExecutiveSummary 6

1.Introduction 10

2.Background 10

2.1DescriptionofWHO’sWASHProgramintheAsiaPacific 11

2.2ScopeofEvaluation 11

2.3Waterqualitysurveillanceandmanagement 12

2.4WASHinhealthcarefacilities 12

3.Evaluationpurposeandobjectives 13

3.1Evaluationpurposeandapproach 13

3.2Evaluationprinciples 14

4.Evaluationmethodology 14

4.1Evaluationquestions 14

4.2Datacollection 14

4.3Datastorage,analysisandvalidation 15

4.4Ethicsandconsent 16

4.5Limitationsandrisks 16

5.0Findings 18

5.1Effectiveness 18

5.2EvaluationquestionsforEffectiveness 24

5.2.1TowhatextentweretheprogramoutcomesachievedacrossPhilippines,Indonesiaandatthe

regional/globallevel? 24

5.2.2Howappropriateweretheprogram’sstrategiestopromotethesustainabilityofchanges? 27

5.3ValueforMoney 29

5.3.1Howhavedecisionmakingprocessesforimplementationbeencostconscious? 29

5.3.2Towhatextenthasevidenceandlearningbeenusedtoinformprogramdesignand

implementationatthecountrylevel? 30

5.3.3.TowhatextenthaveinnovativeapproachesbeenadoptedtointegrateGEDSIandclimate

resilienceintoprogramming,monitoring,fundinganddecision-making? 31

5.3.4.Towhatextenthaveprocessestoassessandmanageriskandensureaccountabilitybeenadopted

throughouttheprojecttosupportthedeliveryofprojectoutcomes? 34

6.Recommendations 34

Appendix1-EvaluationfocusareaswithinDFAT’sVfMprinciplesframework 38

Appendix2-Evaluationquestionsanddatasourceusedintheevaluation 39

Appendix3–Informationsheetandconsentguide 41

Appendix4.KIIguideforcountrygovernmentstaffandpartners