英文期刊审稿意见模板.docxVIP

英文期刊审稿意见模板

Introduction

I.InitialImpressionandOverallAssessment

*[]Acceptasis

*[]Minorrevisionsrequired

*[]Majorrevisionsrequired

*[]Reject,butencourageresubmissionaftersubstantialrevision

*[]Reject

A.OriginalityandSignificance

*Evaluatethenoveltyoftheresearchquestion,approach,orfindings.

*Assessthecontributiontotheexistingbodyofknowledge.

*Exampleprompts:

*Themanuscriptpresentsa[novel/interesting/valuable]approachto[specificissue].However,theauthorsshouldmoreexplicitlyarticulatehowthisworkadvanc