Analyzing “Homotopy Perturbation Method for Solving Fourth-Order Boundary Value Problem”英文文献资料.docVIP

HindawiPublishingCorporation MathematicalProblemsinEngineering Volume2011,ArticleID296796,7pages doi:10.1155/2011/296796 LettertotheEditor Analyzing“HomotopyPerturbationMethodfor SolvingFourth-OrderBoundaryValueProblem” AfganAslanov Department ofMathematics andComputing, BeykentUniversity,Istanbul,Turkey Correspondence shouldbeaddressedtoAfganAslanov,afganaslanov@ Received29March2011;Accepted 8April2011 Copyright q2011AfganAslanov. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use,distribution, andreproduction in anymedium,providedtheoriginalworkisproperlycited. Weanalyze aprevious paperbyS.T.Mohyud-Din andM.A.Noor2007andshowthemistakes in it. Then, we demonstrate a more e?cient method for solving fourth-order boundary value problems. 1.Problem Letusconsiderthe?fth-orderboundaryproblemofthetype 4 f u,u,u,ugx  1.1 u x withtheboundaryconditions u0α1, u0α2, u1β1, u1β2, 1.2 wherefandgarecontinuousfunctionsandα1,α2,β1,andβ2arerealconstants. The homotopy perturbation method HPM is employed in 1 for solving such problems.Thepurposeofthispaperistopointoutthemistakesinpaper 1anddemonstrate moree?cientmethodforsolvingtheproblemsoftype1.1-1.2. Firstofall,weshowthemistakes. 1 InExample3.2theapproximatesolution uapproxx512480x224.00000000226055x2... 1.3  2 MathematicalProblemsinEngineering oftheproblem u4xuxuxexx?3, u00 u10 u1?e 1.4 u01, , , seeformula3.19in 1hasnorelationshipwiththeexactsolutionuexactx  1?xex. And“error”isatleastuapprox0?uexact0512?e509.28. Itisstrangethattheauthorsdemonstratedthereliabilityoftheerrorsinthetablesee Table3.2in 1. 2 InExample3.3theapproximatesolution uapproxx11.3472?262.827x?3.40768x3... 1.5 oftheproblem  u x 4sin sin2x? ux2, 1.6 u00, u01 , u1sin1, u1cos1 see formula 3.28 in 1 has no relationship with the exa