- 180
- 0
- 约1.78万字
- 约 8页
- 2019-04-19 发布于江西
- 举报
Response to Reviewer Comments
We thank both the reviewers for their thoughtful/useful comments and suggestions. Their comments have improved the manuscript effectively. We have included almost all of their suggestions and below we present a point-by-point response to their comments.
Reviewer A
General Comments
1. Comment on assumptions of linear regression, using a linear regression as opposed to other nonlinear models like artificial neural network, nonlinear regression etc..?
We have checked the distribution of the predictors, and we can report that they are all Normally distributed (figure not shown), so is the Thailand summer monsoon rainfall. Thus, the key assumption of Normal distribution for Linear Regression is satisfied.
Neural network and nonlinear regression models require large sample sizes. While the sample size in this research is relatively small for LOCFIT it does not suffer to the same extent as other nonlinear models. Furthermore, LOCFIT, being “local” in nature has the capability to capture any feature (linear or nonlinear) present in the data.
We found strong linear correlation between the summer rainfall and its predictors (Table 1). Hence, Linear Regression model was used as a benchmark – besides, it is one of the most popular methods in practice.
2. Why CCA type models were not considered as a benchmark..
We thank the reviewer for pointing the two references on CCA, which we have included in the narrative.
CCA type models are better suited for predicting a dependent field (i.e. rainfall at several stations) from field(s) of independent variables (e.g., Tropical SST, SLP etc.). In this paper we are predicting a single time series (i.e. the Thailand summer rainfall index) hence regression based models, such as the ones used here are apt.
3. Issue of non-stationarity….
We agree, that if the relationship between the Thailand summer rainfall and ENSO and other Indo-Pacific predictors changes in time then new predictors have to be identified.
您可能关注的文档
- 2015职业生涯规划(高教版)教学设计:发展要善于把握机遇.doc
- 2015中职生就业与创业指导(北师大版)授课教案:自我探索与职业发展.doc
- 2016年1月奥鹏中医大《天然药物化学》考查课试题答案.doc
- 2016年公司年会策划方案(完整版).pptx
- 2017年一建市政实务已过考生分享资料:备考策略+考试重点总结+考前冲刺点题+背诵口诀.doc
- 2721相似三角形的判定(第2课时)【课件】.ppt
- 6285交通工程经济分析(356#).doc
- 8000只湖羊养殖项目建设可行性研究报告.doc
- 20155集大体院游泳救生员培训、鉴定课程安排.doc
- APP制作大赛作品设计方案_APP作品类.doc
原创力文档

文档评论(0)