对鄂尔多斯盆地能源矿产氯仿沥青Sm.pdf

Vol.31 No.2 : 223-228 Acta Geoscientica Sinica Apr. 2010: 223-228 www.地球学报.com Sm-Nd ——与潘爱芳等商榷 1) 1) 1) 1) 2) , , , , 1), 100083; 2), 065000 摘 要: 2007 34 3 Sm-Nd , , 关键词: Sm-Nd ; ; ; 中图分类号: TE122.133; P597 文献标志码: A 文章编号: 1006-3021(2010)02-223-06 Some Comments on “Sm-Nd Isotope Study of Chloroform S Bitumen in Various Energy Minerals of the Ordos Basin” Written by Pan Aifang and Other Authors G PI Qiao-hui1), LI Yong-quan1), LI Da-peng1), LIU Xue-min1), ZHOU Jian2) 1) China University of Geosciences, Beijing 100083; A 2) Institute of Geophysical and Geochemical Exploration, Langfang, Hebei 065000 Abstract: “Sm-Nd isotope study of chloroform bitumen in various energy minerals of the Ordos basin” written by C PAN Ai-fang et al. was published in “Geology in China” in 2007. They concluded that chloroform bitumen of various energy minerals in Caboniferous-Jurassic strata was derived from the enriched mantle on the basis of Sm-Nd isotopic compositions of chloroform bitumen in oil, coal, uranium–bearing sandstone and their country rocks in the Ordos Basin. Nevertheless, based on re-calculation by corrected methods, the authors have reached the conclusion that the chloroform