但是其能取决.docVIP

PAGE 2 Sun CQ/EEE A7-01 Peer Review Comments- sun cq TOC \o 1-3 \h \z \u HYPERLINK \l _Toc222757739 I Anonymous referees’ comments PAGEREF _Toc222757739 \h 1 HYPERLINK \l _Toc222757740 II peers’ Correspondences PAGEREF _Toc222757740 \h 19 I Anonymous referees’ comments Underneath the fascinations of carbon nanotubes and graphene nanoribbons, Energy and environment sciences, invited in press I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been recommended for publication in Energy Environmental Science subject to revision in line with the attached reports. A: Through a combination of the DFT, the BOLS-TB calculation and some experimental observation, the authors demonstrated the insight into the fascinations of graphene nanoribbons. This paper includes abundant valuable information such as the bond and nonbond formation, dissociation, relaxation and vibration, and the associated energetic and dynamics of charge repopulation, polarization, densification, and localization. Although there have been many theoretical papers studying the edge bonding condition of graphene nanoribbons, it is important in understanding the mechanism of graphene properties and may be published in EES. B: This manuscript dealt with the underneath the fascinations of carbon nanotubes and grapheme nanoribbons. Basically it illustrated the principles of carbon nanotubes (CNT) and graphene nanoribbon (GNR) in depth. However, it would be better to present some more applications on energy (Themed issue: Carbon Nanostructures for Energy), other than all theoretical explanations. It was basically physical illustration on the nanostructure of CNTs and GNRs. It is recommended to be published in ENERGY ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE. Layer and orientation resolved structural relaxation and quantum entrapment of Beryllium surfaces, PCCP 12, 12753 – 59(2010). A: The authors showed that a combination of the theories of tight binding and BOLS correlation and XPS gives useful in