22-10-0051-00-0000-proposed-resolutions-to-comments-related-to-sections-9-6-and-9-7.docVIP

IEEE P802.22Wireless RANs Proposed Resolutions to Comments Related to Sections 9.6 and 9.7 Date: 2010-03-16 Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email Ranga Reddy US Army - CERDEC Ft. Monmouth, NJ Ranga.reddy@ Apurva Mody BAE Systems P.O. Box 868, MER 15-2350, Nashua, NH 03061-0868 404-819-0314 apurva.mody@, apurva_mody@ 1.0 Proposed Resolutions to Comments Related to Sections 9.6 and 9.7 Comment 1167 – Tom Kiernan - Database Service section is currently empty. Proposed Resolution – Counter - Editor to include Sections A, C, D and E from Document 22-09-0123 Rev 15 into Section 9.6 Comments 1169, 1178, 1179 – Superceded by the proposed resolution to Comment 1167 Comment 1168, – Tom Kiernan - Although primitives in this Section are specific to the Cognitive Radio Capabilities, they really deserve to be in their own new section which is combined with the MIB and Management Plane Procedures Proposed Resolution – Counter – The 802.22 ad-hoc group developed the Database Service Interface Document – 22-09-0123 Rev 15 In developing the database related document, these messages changed significantly. Cognitive radio capability ad-hoc recommends that the Contents of Section 9.7.1 be entirely replaced with the contents of Section B in Document 22-09-0123 Rev 15. Comments 1170, 1180, 1182 – Superceded by the proposed resolution for Comment 1168 Comment 1185 – Steve Shellhammer – Sub-clause 9.7.4 and 9.4 are somewhat redundant. As a results there are tables in 9.7.4 that repeat some tables from 9.4. This will lead to lots of errors. Proposed Resolution – Reject - Section 9.4 defines the Spectrum Sensing Function related terminology, and Section 9.7.4 defines the SSF interfaces, messaging and provides a SAP definition. Ultimately, contents of Section 9.7.4 will be included into a new Section on Managemen Plane Procedures and so it is necessary to keep. So, both these sections are necessary at this time. Comment 1191 – Charles Einolf – Tabl