学术论文阅读和陈述6.ppt

* * * * * * * * * * * * What are the research findings? 2: Not only the locations of the different web objects matched across web page categories, but also the grade of congruency or diffusivity, respectively, were similar for almost all web objects. What are the research findings? 3: The expectation of web object location was very similar b/w men and women. What are the research findings? 4: Expectations of web object location were also very similar b/w web design experts and laypeople. What are the research findings? 5: The sizes of the web objects were similar across the three web page types. What are the research findings? 6: The laypeople expected the “external links” and “newsletter links” to be on the left-hand side of the page whereas experts expected them more on the right-hand side. What are the research findings? 7: The patterns of the locations of the web objects differ to those found by Bernand (2001). 8: These differences could indeed be due to changes of the Internet appearance across time. Is there any strength or problem in this study? Well organized Modern technologies are successfully employed Suggestions for future work are well written Is there any strength or problem in this study? 1. The second research question was not fully answered. Specific questions 2: to examine whether diverse user groups have similar or different mental models. Is there any strength or problem in this study? 2. The participants of the study can not represent the internet users. 179 male 334 female 21.7% English 78.3% German 28.2 years (sd=9.1) 13-67 Is there any strength or problem in this study? 3. The introduction part can be shortened Is there any strength or problem in this study? 4. The study of Bernard (2001) should be introduced in more details in the literature review. Is there any strength or problem in this study? 5. The interpretation of the difference between the current study and Bernanrd (2001)’s study is not convincing. … these differences