我国涉外民商事审判存在问题实证分析——以757份裁判文书为依据.pdfVIP

2010 年 10 月 Oct. 2010 时代法学 第8 卷第5 期 如帽entday Law Science Vo1. 8 No.5 我国涉外民商事审判存在问题实证分析 一一以 757 份裁判文书为依据. 郭文利 (南京大学法学院，江算南京 21酬的 摘 要:我阁法院在涉外民商事审判中尚存在诸多问题，大量涉外民商事案件的审理缺乏管格权依据的 闸述或对此给均不详，甚或管辖权依据适用错误。在管辖权异议方面，仲裁协议与法院管辖、债权转让与原合 同管辖权效力间的关系纠貌不清，异议不断。在J像据法适用中，不但大囊的裁判文书没有准据法选择依据，法 律适用支态意态势，而且法院地法被大量适用、P依据法选择方法较为单一等均~I 效相备M-编。对于其他周家 或地区判决以及仲裁裁决的承认与执行方面的严重问题在于对承认与执行的法律依据阐述含糊不详。 关键词:涉外民商事审判:管辖权:法律适用;承认与执行 中团分类号:阴仰 文献标识码:A 立意编号:1672-7的X(却10)05{则17-10 The Empirical Analysis on the Problems in the Foreign-involved Civil and Commercial 丁rial in China: According to 757 Judgments GUO Wen礼i (Laω School 01 Æ叫ÏI飞g Univen峙，N.叫iing ， JiaT啄SU 21栅3 ， Chi阳) Abstract: There are still many problems in the foreigr卜involved civil and commercial trial in China. A lot of trials to the foreign-involved cases either lack of the discussion on the basis of the ju幡 risdiction or without the clearly rea5Oning , even 50me由ing wrong about this 嗣pect. As for the objec- tionωthe ju由diction ，出ey cannot make clear the relationship between the jurisdiction and arbitral 吨reement ， the transfer of creditors rights and the enforcement of the original con忧act. In the 嗣pect of law application , there are not onlyωmany judgments without the basis of the jurisdiction , but al翩 50 emerging 50me defaults resulting from the big amount of the application of chinas law , the con- centrating on 出e only several methods in the law application , etc. For the recognition and execut