有身份者与无身份者共同犯罪探析—以“刘某诈骗、王某滥用职权案”为例.pdfVIP

内容摘要 本文主要研究方向是身份犯与非身份犯共同犯罪的成立及性质认定问题。通过对 “刘某诈骗、王某滥用职权”一案的分析，理顺其中的争议点，结合诸多学者的理论， 提出笔者关于身份犯与非身份犯共同犯罪成立的观点，以及有身份者与无身份者共同犯 罪的性质认定问题。 全文共分为六个部分。 第一、二部分主要介绍了案由和“刘某诈骗、王某滥用职权案”的基本情况，从而 为后面案件争议和法理分析奠定基础。 第三部分，案件的争议焦点，即有身份者与无身份者共同犯罪的成立，以及对该类 共同犯罪的定性。 第四部分，简明阐述了对本案定性持有不同意见的各方观点及其各自的理由。 第五部分，法理分析。首先从理论上对有身份者与无身份者共同犯罪的含义与成立， 展开阐述。然后，结合当前相关的理论争议，就有关有身份者与无身份者共同犯罪的性 质认定问题提出笔者的认定方法。最后，结合本案中的问题探讨了贪污罪中滥用职权行 为构成其他犯罪时，对其作何处理。 第六部分，结论与启示。该部分提出了对刘某诈骗、王某滥用职权行为的定罪意见。 同时，对于案例中涉及的问题进行了适度的延伸，根据当前我国立法及法律实施上的现 状提出了相关的建议。 关键词：滥用职权罪；身份犯；共同犯罪；贪污罪 0 Abstract The main research direction is the problem how to convict of the fellowship in crime that persons with certain identity do it with others without this identity. through the legal analysis of a case of Lius crime of fraud and Wangs crime of abuse , which rationalizes the point of contention in both the theory through the use of many scholars, I make about the viewpoint that how to properly convicted of joint offence , and the method of criminal conviction that how to convict of the fellowship in crime which persons with certain identity do it with others without this identity. The following text is divided into five sections. The first part and the second part introduce the essential complexion of the case of Lius crime of fraud and Wangs crime of abuse, which will lay the foundations for the disputes and legal analysis in the next part. The third part points out the focus of controversy. It mainly includes the viewpoint that how to properly convicted of joint offence , and the method of criminal conviction that how to convict of the fellowship in crime which persons with certain identity do it with others without this identity. The fourth part explains differences of opinions, reasons, and different points of view